12-12-2009, 06:02 PM
I know Guru Gobind Singh Jee have fought against Ahmed Shah Abdali, I also know how sikhs massacred Muslims when they were migrating from India but despite all these acts of sikhs, there is a question of moral standing. If sikhs want independence from Hindu occupation then there is nothing wrong is this, they are just asking for their right and we have to moraly and to some extent militarily support their movement.
In whole of its history, india has never been an state ruled by a particular ideology or a group of people, it is and has been ethnically very diversified region where Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, Socialists and Hindus lived and ruled their controlled territories for centuries. Even in Muslim rulership only Emperor Babar was the one who ruled almost whole Indian territory but at that time he never forced anyone from minority to follow his religion, nor he massacred minorities like Hindus of India are doing nowadays against Christians of Nagaland, Muslims of Assam, Socilists of Naxalbar and Dalits and Sikhs.
According to my views Khalistan is not a dead movement, it is still alive. I have recently read an article where a Sikh freedom fighter wrote that we have neither forgotten, not forgiven 1984 massacre. It is your choice if you do not want to believe me but in past, when I was saying that Taliban of Afghanistan can never be defeated, no one is ready to accept that and even you said that it is not possible for Afghan Taliban to defeat Americans but now you are seeing the worsening situation of Afghanistan and how Afghan Taliban are advancing towards Kabul, even they are now controlling northern parts of Afghanistan which used to be the base camp of Ahmed Shah Massod and his compatriots. At some other occasion, I said that American CIA will force and will use every tactic to remove Ahmedi Najad and will install Khatmi and his cohorts in presidency but even at that time you were not prepared to believe this but it has proved in future days that how Americans intervened in election process of Iran. Anyway, Khalistan is not a dead movement, how can the relatives of martyers of 1984 riots forget their lovedones, who were killed brutally by Hindu government.
As for Regan's Fiqh, I understad what you are trying to say and I have tens of time said that at that time interests of Pakistan and Americans were alligned. So, it was nothing wrong if we were working in co-ordination with Americans and as General Hamid Gul usually says that Americn help was just the "Ghaibe Imdad" of Allah to Pakistan and Afghan Mujahedeens and by the way, raigon's Fiqah has nothing to do with Pakistan's Khalistan support.
Beat Regards,
In whole of its history, india has never been an state ruled by a particular ideology or a group of people, it is and has been ethnically very diversified region where Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, Socialists and Hindus lived and ruled their controlled territories for centuries. Even in Muslim rulership only Emperor Babar was the one who ruled almost whole Indian territory but at that time he never forced anyone from minority to follow his religion, nor he massacred minorities like Hindus of India are doing nowadays against Christians of Nagaland, Muslims of Assam, Socilists of Naxalbar and Dalits and Sikhs.
According to my views Khalistan is not a dead movement, it is still alive. I have recently read an article where a Sikh freedom fighter wrote that we have neither forgotten, not forgiven 1984 massacre. It is your choice if you do not want to believe me but in past, when I was saying that Taliban of Afghanistan can never be defeated, no one is ready to accept that and even you said that it is not possible for Afghan Taliban to defeat Americans but now you are seeing the worsening situation of Afghanistan and how Afghan Taliban are advancing towards Kabul, even they are now controlling northern parts of Afghanistan which used to be the base camp of Ahmed Shah Massod and his compatriots. At some other occasion, I said that American CIA will force and will use every tactic to remove Ahmedi Najad and will install Khatmi and his cohorts in presidency but even at that time you were not prepared to believe this but it has proved in future days that how Americans intervened in election process of Iran. Anyway, Khalistan is not a dead movement, how can the relatives of martyers of 1984 riots forget their lovedones, who were killed brutally by Hindu government.
As for Regan's Fiqh, I understad what you are trying to say and I have tens of time said that at that time interests of Pakistan and Americans were alligned. So, it was nothing wrong if we were working in co-ordination with Americans and as General Hamid Gul usually says that Americn help was just the "Ghaibe Imdad" of Allah to Pakistan and Afghan Mujahedeens and by the way, raigon's Fiqah has nothing to do with Pakistan's Khalistan support.
Beat Regards,
