07-08-2009, 10:15 PM
As Brother awaisaftab has mentioned in his earlier post that and i quote
<b>"Some Ulamahs said that Junaid Jamshed neither a Mufti nor he has read in any Madra so he is not eligible for giving fatwa."</b>
I completely agree with him. Similarly brother awaisaftab doesn't seem to be a mufti to give a fatwa in this regard. As Junaid jamshed's words hav no value similarly awaisaftab's words hav no value. Since brother awaisaftab has claimed that <b>"tapioca starch <i>(used by Lays in Pakistan)</i> .. is derived from pig"</b>...i leave it upto him to provide ANY proof on this matter. In absence of any proof, it would be assumed that the claims of awaisafatb are just a product of mental creativity!
If u giv me choice to believe in either the words of brother awaisaftab or The South African National Halaal Authority and The Central Islamic Committee of Thailand...then it is the call of rationality and God given intelligence, to believe in the words of the latter.
May Allah give HIDAYAH to all of us and forgive our sin of spreading rumors and misinformation.
Pls view the fatwa given by Sheikh Muhammad Saleh Al-Munajjid on the issue of spreading rumours.
http//www.readingislam.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1119503546730&pagename=IslamOnline-English-Ask_Scholar/FatwaE/FatwaEAskTheScholar
<b>"Some Ulamahs said that Junaid Jamshed neither a Mufti nor he has read in any Madra so he is not eligible for giving fatwa."</b>
I completely agree with him. Similarly brother awaisaftab doesn't seem to be a mufti to give a fatwa in this regard. As Junaid jamshed's words hav no value similarly awaisaftab's words hav no value. Since brother awaisaftab has claimed that <b>"tapioca starch <i>(used by Lays in Pakistan)</i> .. is derived from pig"</b>...i leave it upto him to provide ANY proof on this matter. In absence of any proof, it would be assumed that the claims of awaisafatb are just a product of mental creativity!
If u giv me choice to believe in either the words of brother awaisaftab or The South African National Halaal Authority and The Central Islamic Committee of Thailand...then it is the call of rationality and God given intelligence, to believe in the words of the latter.
May Allah give HIDAYAH to all of us and forgive our sin of spreading rumors and misinformation.
Pls view the fatwa given by Sheikh Muhammad Saleh Al-Munajjid on the issue of spreading rumours.
http//www.readingislam.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1119503546730&pagename=IslamOnline-English-Ask_Scholar/FatwaE/FatwaEAskTheScholar
