05-15-2007, 02:10 PM
hi its new member of acccouncy.com,
Amir,
u are comparing CA with ACCA,
well
CA is a government body, works in audit, tax , consultancy.
ICMA ,CIMA they also are government bodies work in management and construcation type accounting.
and in every country u see , there are mostly two bodies just allittle change in name but doing same job alomot,
but i dont know why these new commers like,
ACCAs, PIPFA, MBA finnace wana interfere with them.
if you compare CIMA with ICMA , its right no prblem u can compare ,but i dont know what ACCA and MBA wana prove?, although they have no base where they come from are they government bodies ,
and i call u childish just because u are comaring low level papers of CAT with Module E and F , what are u comparing in both,
but if u compare module A and B papers with CAT , i still say there is absoloutly no comparison , because the coustoms are different.
there passing level , high mental level, strenght and skill thats what ICAP want from a student.
i will say there is no comparison in ACCA and CA ,but u can compair other chartered accountants with pakistani accountants, then it will be a logical comparison otherwise there is nothing to choose between them.
ATIF
Amir,
u are comparing CA with ACCA,
well
CA is a government body, works in audit, tax , consultancy.
ICMA ,CIMA they also are government bodies work in management and construcation type accounting.
and in every country u see , there are mostly two bodies just allittle change in name but doing same job alomot,
but i dont know why these new commers like,
ACCAs, PIPFA, MBA finnace wana interfere with them.
if you compare CIMA with ICMA , its right no prblem u can compare ,but i dont know what ACCA and MBA wana prove?, although they have no base where they come from are they government bodies ,
and i call u childish just because u are comaring low level papers of CAT with Module E and F , what are u comparing in both,
but if u compare module A and B papers with CAT , i still say there is absoloutly no comparison , because the coustoms are different.
there passing level , high mental level, strenght and skill thats what ICAP want from a student.
i will say there is no comparison in ACCA and CA ,but u can compair other chartered accountants with pakistani accountants, then it will be a logical comparison otherwise there is nothing to choose between them.
ATIF