07-20-2009, 02:33 PM
Dear Shikari,
I am student of Stage-V of ICMA and belong from Islamabad. In fact Rawalpindi is my native city. I have done B.Com but before it I did F.Sc. When I started my B.Com the students those who have done I.Com were considered that they have much knowledge of accounting but in the Part-I exam of B.Com mostly student who had done I.Com earlier has compartments. In fact in my opinion Maths,Stats,Physics,Chemistry and Biology broadened the mental level of students,specially Maths broad mental level and create sharpness in the students those study it.
I did my F.Sc with Maths and Stats. These two subjects have been very helpful in all other degrees that I achieved. For Instance I got 95% marks in BMS of B.Com, around 70% marks in Maths and Stats of M.A Economics and finally passed BMS of stage II of ICMA very easily.
The basic reason of low level of knowledge of B.Comers is that the teachers who teach at I.Com and B.Com are mostly M.Commers. In Federal Govt. College of Commerce Islamabad there is only one lecturer who is ACMA (Inter).
I donât know about the students of other universities u say that you live in Multan so your university will be Bhaud-din-Zakria University. But in central and northern Punjab many group of colleges have established, providing education mainly in commerce, these group of colleges have created their monopoly in Punjab University and influence syllabus and examination process. In 2003 Punjab University was revising the syllabus of B.Com these colleges disturbed very bitterly the whole process of revision of syllabus. One of eminent professor of Federal Govt.cllege of Commerce says that the topic of cash flow statement was being including in the syllabus but a professor of Hailey College of Commerce (Dept of Commerce of Punjab University),who have also a link with a group of college, strongly opposed this inclusion.
This group of colleges uses all means to protect their students and for making them as position holders. I suggest to all that please see the rules and regulation of exams of Punjab University for B.Sc and B.A and compare these rules and regulation with the rules of exams for B.Com. You will surely observe that there is large difference between the two. Punjab University takes exams of Part I and II of B.A/B.Sc combinely. If a students fail in two subject he will have to re-appear in all subject and a student who has compartment only in one subject is allowed to appear in supplementary exams,which are held after two/three months of declaration of result of BA/B.S. On the other hand the university does not take the exams of B.Com Part-I&II together if a student of B.Com Part-I who fails in 3/4 paper of said exam is allowed to appear in supplementary exams during his part-II studies again if such students remains failed to pass up to 2 papers of Part-I then he will be also entitle to appear in B.Com part-II exams.
See and observe what unjust and unrealistic rules and regulation .
I am not against the University of Punjab I have archived my degrees from this university,i.e B.Com and M.A (Eco), I am only against those selfish professors who are making B.Com a child's play.
As far as your view about bad knowledge of accounting of B.Commers, I just want to say that not all students of B.Com are bad accounting. The other thing is that Maths and other science subject broadened the mental level of a student. Maths is the mother of all subjects beside it the person who is considered the founder of double entry accounting, Luca Pacioli, was an eminent mathematician. The philosophers who played a vital role in the development of Economics were also mathematicians.
Regards,
Awais Aftab
I am student of Stage-V of ICMA and belong from Islamabad. In fact Rawalpindi is my native city. I have done B.Com but before it I did F.Sc. When I started my B.Com the students those who have done I.Com were considered that they have much knowledge of accounting but in the Part-I exam of B.Com mostly student who had done I.Com earlier has compartments. In fact in my opinion Maths,Stats,Physics,Chemistry and Biology broadened the mental level of students,specially Maths broad mental level and create sharpness in the students those study it.
I did my F.Sc with Maths and Stats. These two subjects have been very helpful in all other degrees that I achieved. For Instance I got 95% marks in BMS of B.Com, around 70% marks in Maths and Stats of M.A Economics and finally passed BMS of stage II of ICMA very easily.
The basic reason of low level of knowledge of B.Comers is that the teachers who teach at I.Com and B.Com are mostly M.Commers. In Federal Govt. College of Commerce Islamabad there is only one lecturer who is ACMA (Inter).
I donât know about the students of other universities u say that you live in Multan so your university will be Bhaud-din-Zakria University. But in central and northern Punjab many group of colleges have established, providing education mainly in commerce, these group of colleges have created their monopoly in Punjab University and influence syllabus and examination process. In 2003 Punjab University was revising the syllabus of B.Com these colleges disturbed very bitterly the whole process of revision of syllabus. One of eminent professor of Federal Govt.cllege of Commerce says that the topic of cash flow statement was being including in the syllabus but a professor of Hailey College of Commerce (Dept of Commerce of Punjab University),who have also a link with a group of college, strongly opposed this inclusion.
This group of colleges uses all means to protect their students and for making them as position holders. I suggest to all that please see the rules and regulation of exams of Punjab University for B.Sc and B.A and compare these rules and regulation with the rules of exams for B.Com. You will surely observe that there is large difference between the two. Punjab University takes exams of Part I and II of B.A/B.Sc combinely. If a students fail in two subject he will have to re-appear in all subject and a student who has compartment only in one subject is allowed to appear in supplementary exams,which are held after two/three months of declaration of result of BA/B.S. On the other hand the university does not take the exams of B.Com Part-I&II together if a student of B.Com Part-I who fails in 3/4 paper of said exam is allowed to appear in supplementary exams during his part-II studies again if such students remains failed to pass up to 2 papers of Part-I then he will be also entitle to appear in B.Com part-II exams.
See and observe what unjust and unrealistic rules and regulation .
I am not against the University of Punjab I have archived my degrees from this university,i.e B.Com and M.A (Eco), I am only against those selfish professors who are making B.Com a child's play.
As far as your view about bad knowledge of accounting of B.Commers, I just want to say that not all students of B.Com are bad accounting. The other thing is that Maths and other science subject broadened the mental level of a student. Maths is the mother of all subjects beside it the person who is considered the founder of double entry accounting, Luca Pacioli, was an eminent mathematician. The philosophers who played a vital role in the development of Economics were also mathematicians.
Regards,
Awais Aftab
