06-27-2010, 12:36 AM
<blockquote id="quote"><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, san" id="quote">quote<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"><i>Originally posted by VITAL</i>
<br />Arsenal I donot make this topic to discuss what you called the future of ACCA in this forum. The CA students are never interested in the extent of exemptions granted or will be granted to ACCA students. I am not interested in the ICAP policy regarding this whether past or future. We simply want improvements in our study material and simply want new developments in CA profession to meet the demands of what is happening around the world and will be happened. To achieve this we should follow relevent techniques of ICAEW (copy is not the right word) because ICAEW is the benchmark not only for ICAP but also for ACCA.Yes Kamran Bhai is right we are not behind. our examination policy is ok. problem lies in study material sorts of things.
I am waiting for something new that is beneficial for CA not the new affecting ACCA.
But unfortunately CA students turned mute spectators and I found myself in needless discussion with ACCAs. So plz donât start CA vs ACCA debate. Your ideas regarding the new developments will be welcomed.
<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"></font id="quote"></blockquote id="quote">
Vital CA/ACCA debate to fazol hai.
But as u r saying that "ICAEW is a benchmark" might be acceptable for us Pakistanis but few others don't believe it.For example India.ICAEW award maximam 14 papers(just case staudy required to be passed) exemptions to Indian CAs while ICA-INDIA require full ICAEW members to pass full Final stage i.e 4 papers.Agar dekha jai to ICAEW -ICA(INDIA) k MOU k taht to ICAEW jhuka hai.In 2007/08 ICAEW launched its program in India.ICA-INDIA went to court and halted ICAEW program in INDIA.Then ICAEW negotiated, signed a less favourable MOU, and then re-entered INDIA.It was because India is a big market.In 2008 ICAEW had only 9000 students pursuing their CA worldwide and they r struggling to lure new candidates in greater number.Its current membership is about 132000.The main sourse of INCOME for an accounting body is its students.In India about 120000 students r pursuing CA so it is a big market which ICAEW eyed.So bottom line is k ICA-INDIA nay apne ongoing curriculum say hi ICAEW key sath equal level(even better level) peh MOU kia.They didn't percieved it as a benchmark.
<br />Arsenal I donot make this topic to discuss what you called the future of ACCA in this forum. The CA students are never interested in the extent of exemptions granted or will be granted to ACCA students. I am not interested in the ICAP policy regarding this whether past or future. We simply want improvements in our study material and simply want new developments in CA profession to meet the demands of what is happening around the world and will be happened. To achieve this we should follow relevent techniques of ICAEW (copy is not the right word) because ICAEW is the benchmark not only for ICAP but also for ACCA.Yes Kamran Bhai is right we are not behind. our examination policy is ok. problem lies in study material sorts of things.
I am waiting for something new that is beneficial for CA not the new affecting ACCA.
But unfortunately CA students turned mute spectators and I found myself in needless discussion with ACCAs. So plz donât start CA vs ACCA debate. Your ideas regarding the new developments will be welcomed.
<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"></font id="quote"></blockquote id="quote">
Vital CA/ACCA debate to fazol hai.
But as u r saying that "ICAEW is a benchmark" might be acceptable for us Pakistanis but few others don't believe it.For example India.ICAEW award maximam 14 papers(just case staudy required to be passed) exemptions to Indian CAs while ICA-INDIA require full ICAEW members to pass full Final stage i.e 4 papers.Agar dekha jai to ICAEW -ICA(INDIA) k MOU k taht to ICAEW jhuka hai.In 2007/08 ICAEW launched its program in India.ICA-INDIA went to court and halted ICAEW program in INDIA.Then ICAEW negotiated, signed a less favourable MOU, and then re-entered INDIA.It was because India is a big market.In 2008 ICAEW had only 9000 students pursuing their CA worldwide and they r struggling to lure new candidates in greater number.Its current membership is about 132000.The main sourse of INCOME for an accounting body is its students.In India about 120000 students r pursuing CA so it is a big market which ICAEW eyed.So bottom line is k ICA-INDIA nay apne ongoing curriculum say hi ICAEW key sath equal level(even better level) peh MOU kia.They didn't percieved it as a benchmark.
