08-25-2010, 02:10 AM
Dears
I think some causes of such behaviour are, we are very emotional, believe everything without thinking, jump to conclusions very fast, show sheeps behaviour (i.e. Bher Chal), have not developed individual independent thinking based on inner justice etc.
Most of us have read the details of this incident. Some of my questions to all of us are, is it still needed to see "the movie" on youtube to feel the heinousness of this collective crime? Why we could not restrain ourselves from viewing it on various websites? Can't we imagine or perceive it from our imagination? Is it necessary to see it? Is it part of our collective nature that whenever any incident or accident happens somewhere like on street, we must go there "to see/ view" and then say "chch chch baychara" and pass by. Are we addicted to view "madaari kay tamashay", now even on youtube? Are we not extra curious? Or is there any evil inside us who get satiety by viewing? Though commenting against, but are we not monsters from inside who still wanna view it? Many of us were present there physically, could not stop it, but must remained there to view it. And now we know what happened, but are watching on youtube more and more. What difference would it make now? Is viewing this movie not a continuation of "bay-hurmati" of corpses?
By the way, though I know that it is available on youtube, but did not try to see it, as I think it is even worst to see recording of happening of such a heinous crime.
I read that media in Pakistan aired this incident with very minimal censor. Is it necessary to show such incidents without controled censorship knowingly that kids, women, old, and week heart people would see it too. Though Mr. Choudhary took actions against the criminals which is good, but should he not at-least suggest media to restrain in ethical limits (without compromising gravity of news item) while reporting such incidents. At-least now he should put a publication ban on this "movie" to reduce the pain of effected family, to protect their privacy, and to stop further "bay-hurmati" of corpses.
Now some food for thoughts about Eid-ul-Adha and Qurbani. I know it is administartively difficult in our country, but is it not possible to perform act of Qurbani in walled buildings (eg gov't schools or markets) where public (specially kids) should not have open access while cutting throat of animals, and only selected licensed butchers would do it, and not owner of animal. So it would not happen on every street and kids wouldn't see it from very initial age of learning and adopting behaviours which remain with them for rest of life. Moulanas should not have objection on it as if it can happen during Hajj and in many other countries then why not in our country.
If it is difficult to do it this way, then at-least can't we ask our kids not to view it and can't we ask the butcher to do it by himself rather than we cut it by our hands. Perhaps, to most of you this would resonate a distant thing or weird, but remember such things go inch by inch and keep accumulating.
Regards
I think some causes of such behaviour are, we are very emotional, believe everything without thinking, jump to conclusions very fast, show sheeps behaviour (i.e. Bher Chal), have not developed individual independent thinking based on inner justice etc.
Most of us have read the details of this incident. Some of my questions to all of us are, is it still needed to see "the movie" on youtube to feel the heinousness of this collective crime? Why we could not restrain ourselves from viewing it on various websites? Can't we imagine or perceive it from our imagination? Is it necessary to see it? Is it part of our collective nature that whenever any incident or accident happens somewhere like on street, we must go there "to see/ view" and then say "chch chch baychara" and pass by. Are we addicted to view "madaari kay tamashay", now even on youtube? Are we not extra curious? Or is there any evil inside us who get satiety by viewing? Though commenting against, but are we not monsters from inside who still wanna view it? Many of us were present there physically, could not stop it, but must remained there to view it. And now we know what happened, but are watching on youtube more and more. What difference would it make now? Is viewing this movie not a continuation of "bay-hurmati" of corpses?
By the way, though I know that it is available on youtube, but did not try to see it, as I think it is even worst to see recording of happening of such a heinous crime.
I read that media in Pakistan aired this incident with very minimal censor. Is it necessary to show such incidents without controled censorship knowingly that kids, women, old, and week heart people would see it too. Though Mr. Choudhary took actions against the criminals which is good, but should he not at-least suggest media to restrain in ethical limits (without compromising gravity of news item) while reporting such incidents. At-least now he should put a publication ban on this "movie" to reduce the pain of effected family, to protect their privacy, and to stop further "bay-hurmati" of corpses.
Now some food for thoughts about Eid-ul-Adha and Qurbani. I know it is administartively difficult in our country, but is it not possible to perform act of Qurbani in walled buildings (eg gov't schools or markets) where public (specially kids) should not have open access while cutting throat of animals, and only selected licensed butchers would do it, and not owner of animal. So it would not happen on every street and kids wouldn't see it from very initial age of learning and adopting behaviours which remain with them for rest of life. Moulanas should not have objection on it as if it can happen during Hajj and in many other countries then why not in our country.
If it is difficult to do it this way, then at-least can't we ask our kids not to view it and can't we ask the butcher to do it by himself rather than we cut it by our hands. Perhaps, to most of you this would resonate a distant thing or weird, but remember such things go inch by inch and keep accumulating.
Regards
