10-11-2007, 01:46 AM
Refering to your original post Kamran Sb.
It appeared that you denied my point where I tried to prove some contradiction in your thoughts. You beleive that HR policies are necessary for the success of organization and getting the employees motivated. But in your opinion this view does not very much applies to CA firms as we are students not employees, and such things are primarily designed for employees and not for students. However, you also said that some real student friendly and just HR policies are there in some of the good firms. The word "some" is crucial definitely some of the things are right at some of the places. But before that we are yet to conclude that what is right or wrong. Is there any need for any leniency or not. (you have categorically denied it earlier)
Another thing is that you accused me to take just one aspect of your points (and a totally un required reference to a Quranic verse was twice repeated in your post). But I did not find some logical reasoning for your comments.
You keep on advising what CA students should be doing during the period of trainig, their main focus should be on studies bala bala. I guess even a kid knows all these things so our elders are in the habit of wasting words.
Now as you have agreed that some difference does exist between healthy discussion and debate for the sake of debate, so I will not include here some points regarding time machine and going abroad.
Hoping to hear something objective, logical and rational form you but I know I am hoping against hope
It appeared that you denied my point where I tried to prove some contradiction in your thoughts. You beleive that HR policies are necessary for the success of organization and getting the employees motivated. But in your opinion this view does not very much applies to CA firms as we are students not employees, and such things are primarily designed for employees and not for students. However, you also said that some real student friendly and just HR policies are there in some of the good firms. The word "some" is crucial definitely some of the things are right at some of the places. But before that we are yet to conclude that what is right or wrong. Is there any need for any leniency or not. (you have categorically denied it earlier)
Another thing is that you accused me to take just one aspect of your points (and a totally un required reference to a Quranic verse was twice repeated in your post). But I did not find some logical reasoning for your comments.
You keep on advising what CA students should be doing during the period of trainig, their main focus should be on studies bala bala. I guess even a kid knows all these things so our elders are in the habit of wasting words.
Now as you have agreed that some difference does exist between healthy discussion and debate for the sake of debate, so I will not include here some points regarding time machine and going abroad.
Hoping to hear something objective, logical and rational form you but I know I am hoping against hope
