10-17-2004, 08:31 AM
<BLOCKQUOTE id=quote><font size=1 face="Verdana, Tahoma, Arial" id=quote>quote<hr height=1 noshade id=quote>Well ppl i always try to get myself out of this discusion any way
its tempting always
well
the comparisons shud me made by those who belong to both fields (mind u not at the begineer level)
Me being the one of them has following points
Yes yes yes...acca's exam testing is 10 times better than iczp,, but CA students mentality is in turn 10 times better than ACCA's average 55% qualified person....but i bet the person whoseo average in core pares in 60% and above has all capabilities to do CA...i affirm u all
One thing more we all confuses exams with practcal training and with job matket
ACCA's exam testing is best yet training requirement is very relaxed..any one in pakistan just showing 3 years experiance by wuteva means is considered to be a member......so training in ACCA is 10 times weaker....plus how can acca's beat ca's market rather CA's can not beat the monopoly of qualified CA's from good firms as regard Multinational and big local giants than to talk of ACCA
Training of a CA is so composed i tell u all who are unaware.....its just that 4 years raghra makes u gold from kundan,,,,,
believe me or not...
And if ACCA wants to compete CA i know how they can....
just convet revenue authoriues (CBR) that they ca practice tax
Convey SECP the same
Make a tough and monitored training procedure especially for pakistan
Sponser the big ginats for hiring ACCA's
Advertise and also customise the exam passing criteria for pakistan (i.e a tough one otherwise i see a demand suply problem
bye
<hr height=1 noshade id=quote></BLOCKQUOTE id=quote></font id=quote><font face="Verdana, Tahoma, Arial" size=2 id=quote>
just tell me how did you come up with the number "10".
As you said above ACCA exams are 10 times better than CA and CAs are "mentally" 10 times better than ACCAs.
the rest of the crap is digestable not necessarily agreeable.
azeem
its tempting always
well
the comparisons shud me made by those who belong to both fields (mind u not at the begineer level)
Me being the one of them has following points
Yes yes yes...acca's exam testing is 10 times better than iczp,, but CA students mentality is in turn 10 times better than ACCA's average 55% qualified person....but i bet the person whoseo average in core pares in 60% and above has all capabilities to do CA...i affirm u all
One thing more we all confuses exams with practcal training and with job matket
ACCA's exam testing is best yet training requirement is very relaxed..any one in pakistan just showing 3 years experiance by wuteva means is considered to be a member......so training in ACCA is 10 times weaker....plus how can acca's beat ca's market rather CA's can not beat the monopoly of qualified CA's from good firms as regard Multinational and big local giants than to talk of ACCA
Training of a CA is so composed i tell u all who are unaware.....its just that 4 years raghra makes u gold from kundan,,,,,
believe me or not...
And if ACCA wants to compete CA i know how they can....
just convet revenue authoriues (CBR) that they ca practice tax
Convey SECP the same
Make a tough and monitored training procedure especially for pakistan
Sponser the big ginats for hiring ACCA's
Advertise and also customise the exam passing criteria for pakistan (i.e a tough one otherwise i see a demand suply problem
bye
<hr height=1 noshade id=quote></BLOCKQUOTE id=quote></font id=quote><font face="Verdana, Tahoma, Arial" size=2 id=quote>
just tell me how did you come up with the number "10".
As you said above ACCA exams are 10 times better than CA and CAs are "mentally" 10 times better than ACCAs.
the rest of the crap is digestable not necessarily agreeable.
azeem