07-12-2010, 10:13 PM
Dear Ajnabi,
With due regard, Ulema of every Muslak are repectful for me as they are Predecessors of Holy Prophet Muhammad SAW. However, i cant blindly act upon the saying of any Alim of the world unless i will not find proper and authetic reference of Holy Quran and Saying of Prophet Muhammad SA. Nothing is authentic unless it is properly referred to The Holy Quran and Prophet Muhammad SAW. I am completely disagreed with you that every thing mentioned in such books are authentic and need no verification at all. There may not be chances of deliberate modifications but there are always chances of errors and misunderstanding as these books are written by respectful Ulemas and they are human being not angels who could not commit any mistake. So, i would refer you to the Ayat of Holy Quran.
" (1) Ittakhathoo ahbarahum waruhbanahum arbaban min dooni Allahi waalmaseeha ibna maryama wama omiroo illa liyaAAbudoo ilahan wahidan la ilaha illa huwa subhanahu AAamma yushrikoona
At-Taubah, Chapter #9, Verse #31)
So, please read also the context and its narrations of different scholars. So, it is very vague argument that I book written by Ulema of X maslik is authentic and Umlema of Y maslik is not authentic. So, kindly do not make Ulema as your RAB as said by Holy Quran. When you will read the context of this Aya you will come to know that without considering the HOLY QURAN if some one is blindly acting upon Fatwas of Ulemas so he is doing an act like Christian who are subject of this Aya.
If not satisfied please reply.
With due regard, Ulema of every Muslak are repectful for me as they are Predecessors of Holy Prophet Muhammad SAW. However, i cant blindly act upon the saying of any Alim of the world unless i will not find proper and authetic reference of Holy Quran and Saying of Prophet Muhammad SA. Nothing is authentic unless it is properly referred to The Holy Quran and Prophet Muhammad SAW. I am completely disagreed with you that every thing mentioned in such books are authentic and need no verification at all. There may not be chances of deliberate modifications but there are always chances of errors and misunderstanding as these books are written by respectful Ulemas and they are human being not angels who could not commit any mistake. So, i would refer you to the Ayat of Holy Quran.
" (1) Ittakhathoo ahbarahum waruhbanahum arbaban min dooni Allahi waalmaseeha ibna maryama wama omiroo illa liyaAAbudoo ilahan wahidan la ilaha illa huwa subhanahu AAamma yushrikoona
At-Taubah, Chapter #9, Verse #31)
So, please read also the context and its narrations of different scholars. So, it is very vague argument that I book written by Ulema of X maslik is authentic and Umlema of Y maslik is not authentic. So, kindly do not make Ulema as your RAB as said by Holy Quran. When you will read the context of this Aya you will come to know that without considering the HOLY QURAN if some one is blindly acting upon Fatwas of Ulemas so he is doing an act like Christian who are subject of this Aya.
If not satisfied please reply.
