07-30-2006, 02:08 AM
Sir, coming to your answer first, you did not get my question. I did not ask about largest Muslim country.
Sir, the country having largest Muslim population is India, followed by Pakistan, then comes Indonesia and Bangladesh is at No. 4.
The reason of asking this question was never to test your knowledge, I just tried to relate this with the topic. I hope you do understand. Having more than 20 million Muslims in India leaves much questions about two nations theory.
Pracs, what you wrote is exactly what we are taught in Pakistan Studies. Calling Congress stubborn and short sighted and considering that Muslim League was the best party, you are justified to think like that when you are a Pakistani. But in this case you can't claim to be rational. On rational grounds things have to be taken with a different approach.
Sir, I disagree at one point Pakistan becoming a reality was not such an out of this world type thing.
I had some experiences of talking with Indian Muslims when I was in KSA. They were as patriot with their country as we are with ours. And, they were absolutely convinced that partition of Sub Continent was reasonless, and according to their point of view this point was proved the day when Pakistan was divided.
In Lahore I met with some people, quite experts of political sciences, who thought that boundaries on the base of religion are not justified. Things like as I mentioned in my last post plus things like neo world order they had as their logics. I hope you have the idea that a majority in Karachi and some in my part of the country exist who doesnât agree with Quaid-e-Azam.
Pracs, I am a patriot Pakistani, and all above does not exactly depicts my thinking. Saying that two-nation theory was wrong leaves us with no reason to exist. I agree with all what you said, but only what I wanted to say is we canât believe all this with a closed mind, we need to be rational
Sir, the country having largest Muslim population is India, followed by Pakistan, then comes Indonesia and Bangladesh is at No. 4.
The reason of asking this question was never to test your knowledge, I just tried to relate this with the topic. I hope you do understand. Having more than 20 million Muslims in India leaves much questions about two nations theory.
Pracs, what you wrote is exactly what we are taught in Pakistan Studies. Calling Congress stubborn and short sighted and considering that Muslim League was the best party, you are justified to think like that when you are a Pakistani. But in this case you can't claim to be rational. On rational grounds things have to be taken with a different approach.
Sir, I disagree at one point Pakistan becoming a reality was not such an out of this world type thing.
I had some experiences of talking with Indian Muslims when I was in KSA. They were as patriot with their country as we are with ours. And, they were absolutely convinced that partition of Sub Continent was reasonless, and according to their point of view this point was proved the day when Pakistan was divided.
In Lahore I met with some people, quite experts of political sciences, who thought that boundaries on the base of religion are not justified. Things like as I mentioned in my last post plus things like neo world order they had as their logics. I hope you have the idea that a majority in Karachi and some in my part of the country exist who doesnât agree with Quaid-e-Azam.
Pracs, I am a patriot Pakistani, and all above does not exactly depicts my thinking. Saying that two-nation theory was wrong leaves us with no reason to exist. I agree with all what you said, but only what I wanted to say is we canât believe all this with a closed mind, we need to be rational
