09-26-2006, 02:55 AM
We as a nation is not being questioned, neither any Pakistani would allow this. So that is never the discussion here.
Quite unjust you had been while discussing Indian Muslims, and this depicts lack of knowledge of our youth on this subject.
Claiming that India is an un natural union of states and they would soon seperate, what do you say about Pakistan? What do we have in common except our religion.
The magic lines did not convey much of sense to me. I don't think that Indian Muslims accuse Pakistanis of betraying them, however, in my opinion they are the sufferors of this partition. They just refer this partition as unnecessary.
Your recomendations (though some of them sound pretty valid) does not seem very much practicable. And, people from minority provinces wont agree to them. The evil of provincialism has become a threat for us.
Decentralization seems one of the solutions, and this is what people of smaller provinces demad. The concept of federation like ours has become obsolete in the present world, and it is only found in kingdoms. This issue, however, is not as simple as this, and in my personal opinion its not practicable in a country like ours where human skills are in one part, majority of the natural resources are in the province with the population of just 6 million and covering 43% of the total area.
Quite unjust you had been while discussing Indian Muslims, and this depicts lack of knowledge of our youth on this subject.
Claiming that India is an un natural union of states and they would soon seperate, what do you say about Pakistan? What do we have in common except our religion.
The magic lines did not convey much of sense to me. I don't think that Indian Muslims accuse Pakistanis of betraying them, however, in my opinion they are the sufferors of this partition. They just refer this partition as unnecessary.
Your recomendations (though some of them sound pretty valid) does not seem very much practicable. And, people from minority provinces wont agree to them. The evil of provincialism has become a threat for us.
Decentralization seems one of the solutions, and this is what people of smaller provinces demad. The concept of federation like ours has become obsolete in the present world, and it is only found in kingdoms. This issue, however, is not as simple as this, and in my personal opinion its not practicable in a country like ours where human skills are in one part, majority of the natural resources are in the province with the population of just 6 million and covering 43% of the total area.
