These are completly different areas and therefore have no bearings to be compared, depends what you background and experience is and what your preference for the future is
Well CISA is a complete qualification if you have an IT degree as a major followed by relevant work experience. We have people working here as IT auditors with the same background,. I am talking about Pakistani professionals here
and CIA is a complete qualification as well. It may not have grounds in Pak but here in Saudi Arabia (and almost in whole of the Middle East), many CIAs are getting quite hefty pay checks.