03-08-2010, 03:26 AM
Dear Awais,
Have you been practicing what you are preaching? If someone claims that he is Muslim, why you are insisting him to declare him non-muslim? Kamran very rightly quoted incident of Hazrat Ali (R.A), did open his heart and see that Zaid Hamid is non-muslim? We just canât assess someone the basis of the past. Do you know that who damaged Muslims in War of Ditch and Khazwa-e-Auhad the most, before âEmanâ. It was Khalid Bin Al-Waleed and Akerma bin Abu Jahal. Later these were the people who fought for Islam and eliminate Fitna-e-Musilima. These were the people who shattered density of Iran and Roman Empire. Hinda (RA) the bitterest enemy of Islam, fought against Roman, when Islam soldiers, were losing the battle. For detailed reading see âSword of Allahâ by Col. Ikram. What you are saying is an illogical reasoning to defame Zaid Hamid.
As far as JI is concerned, it is also another big chapter. We all are well aware of these people. I donât want to open this chapter because it would definitely hurt religious feelings of many forum people. At least I just canât dare to discuss validity of any Hadeeth, because I donât have in-depth knowledge of Quan and Sunna and Fiqah. I think our great scholars during the history of 1400 have done great work on this. You can refer to their work and they have discussed each âwordâ, I am not exaggerating, each word of hundred of thousand of ahadeeth. If you read Tafseer ibne Kathir, he discussed Bissmila on 4-5 pages. This is a master peace discussion.
I do not challenge your family back ground. I am just trying to make you understand because I know there were many prophet whose even family members did not accept Islam and father of Ibrahim (AS) was Idol maker.
Regards,
GREAT KHANS
Have you been practicing what you are preaching? If someone claims that he is Muslim, why you are insisting him to declare him non-muslim? Kamran very rightly quoted incident of Hazrat Ali (R.A), did open his heart and see that Zaid Hamid is non-muslim? We just canât assess someone the basis of the past. Do you know that who damaged Muslims in War of Ditch and Khazwa-e-Auhad the most, before âEmanâ. It was Khalid Bin Al-Waleed and Akerma bin Abu Jahal. Later these were the people who fought for Islam and eliminate Fitna-e-Musilima. These were the people who shattered density of Iran and Roman Empire. Hinda (RA) the bitterest enemy of Islam, fought against Roman, when Islam soldiers, were losing the battle. For detailed reading see âSword of Allahâ by Col. Ikram. What you are saying is an illogical reasoning to defame Zaid Hamid.
As far as JI is concerned, it is also another big chapter. We all are well aware of these people. I donât want to open this chapter because it would definitely hurt religious feelings of many forum people. At least I just canât dare to discuss validity of any Hadeeth, because I donât have in-depth knowledge of Quan and Sunna and Fiqah. I think our great scholars during the history of 1400 have done great work on this. You can refer to their work and they have discussed each âwordâ, I am not exaggerating, each word of hundred of thousand of ahadeeth. If you read Tafseer ibne Kathir, he discussed Bissmila on 4-5 pages. This is a master peace discussion.
I do not challenge your family back ground. I am just trying to make you understand because I know there were many prophet whose even family members did not accept Islam and father of Ibrahim (AS) was Idol maker.
Regards,
GREAT KHANS
